The essay

  1. Home
  2. Tracks
  3. The essay
  4. Choosing a story to tell
A woman in glasses thinking at her desk

Part 2 of 62 min readUpdated November 18, 2026

Choosing a story to tell

Many scholarship essays are built around one story, and choosing it well does more for the essay than any later polishing. This helps you gather possible moments, test them against the prompt and settle on one you can tell honestly in the space allowed.

Gathering possible moments

Spend twenty minutes listing moments rather than achievements: the morning you opened the family store alone, the conversation that changed your plans, the first time a project failed in front of other people. A moment has a place, a time and something that happened, which gives the reader a scene to picture.

Draw from every part of your life, including work, family duties and things you taught yourself. Committees read plenty of essays about a big game or a service trip, and a smaller scene described closely often says more about the writer.

A moment has a place, a time and something that happened, which gives the reader a scene to picture.

Testing each moment against the prompt

For each moment, try finishing a sentence that begins with the prompt's main question. If the prompt asks about a challenge, write what the challenge was, what you did and what changed. A moment that produces a clear sentence is worth keeping on the list.

Ask whether the story shows something your activities list and transcript cannot. The committee already sees your grades and your roles. The essay is where it learns how you think, what you care about and how you respond when something goes wrong.

Choosing what you are comfortable sharing

Some prompts invite stories about hardship, illness, loss or money troubles at home. You decide how much to share, and an essay can be strong without every detail. Focus on what you did and what you learned, and keep the part you would rather not discuss to a sentence or two.

Once you have chosen, tell the story aloud to someone you trust in under two minutes. If it holds together when spoken, it will usually hold together on the page, and the listener's questions show you where the reader will need more.

Steps to take this week

  • List ten moments rather than ten achievements
  • Finish the prompt's main question for your three strongest moments
  • Decide which details you would rather keep private
  • Tell your chosen story aloud to someone you trust

Who to ask

An English teacher or counselor who can listen to your ideas

A good essay story is a specific moment that answers the prompt and shows the committee something the rest of the application cannot.

Tags:The essayAll articlesPlanner

Get scholarship season reminders

Hear about new articles on the piece of the application you choose, by email, and by text if you tick the box.

Sign up for updates